VoiceDDB
Politics • Culture • News
oDDBall analysis of conservative politics with a libertarian economic conservative twist. Small government, big freedom.
Interested? Want to learn more about the community?
September 21, 2021
Via Oddball

A critique of masking policies.

Where are the random controlled trials?

Where are the legislatures?

What are the costs?
https://vivabarneslaw.locals.com/post/1090955/https-podcasts-google-com-feed-ahr0chm6ly9jbgfyzw1vbnryzxzpzxdvzmjvb2tzlmxpynn5bi5jb20vcnnz-episod

Interested? Want to learn more about the community?
What else you may like…
Videos
Posts
Articles
00:01:07
November 27, 2022
Jingle Bell Rock

Jingle bell, jingle bell, jingle bell rock
Jingle bells swing and jingle bells ring
Snowin' and blowin' up bushels of fun
Now the jingle hop has begun

Jingle bell, jingle bell, jingle bell rock
Jingle bells chime in jingle bell time
Dancin' and prancin' in Jingle Bell Square
In the frosty air

What a bright time, it's the right time
To rock the night away
Jingle bell time is a swell time
To go glidin' in a one-horse sleigh

Giddy-up jingle horse, pick up your feet
Jingle around the clock
Mix and a-mingle in the jinglin' feet
That's the jingle bell rock

Jingle bell, jingle bell, jingle bell rock
Jingle bell chime in jingle bell time
Dancin' and prancin' in Jingle Bell Square
In the frosty air

What a bright time, it's the right time
To rock the night away
Jingle bell time is a swell time
To go glidin' in a one-horse sleigh

Giddy-up jingle horse, pick up your feet
Jingle around the clock
Mix and a-mingle in the jinglin' feet
That's the jingle bell
That's the jingle bell
That's the jingle...

00:02:04
September 01, 2021
Intro to Locals for the Conservative Voice

David Daniel Ball calls himself the Conservative Voice.

I'm a teacher with three decades experience teaching math to high school kids.I also work with first graders and kids in between first grade and high school. I know the legends of why Hypatia's dad is remembered through his contribution to Math theory. And I know the legend of why followers of Godel had thought he had disproved God's existence.

I'm not a preacher, but I am a Christian who has written over 28 books all of which include some reference to my faith. Twelve blog books on world history and current affairs, detailing world events , births and marriages on each day of the year, organised by month. Twelve books on the background to and history of Bible Quotes. One Bible quote per day for a year. An intro to a science fiction series I'm planning, post apocalyptic cyber punk. An autobiography with short story collections.

I'm known in Australia for my failure as a whistleblower over the negligence death of a school boy. ...

00:01:50
September 04, 2026
Should violent criminals be made fat? Grok says 'no'

No. Transferring gut bacteria from an obese person into a violent criminal is not a reliable, ethical, or effective way to make them “fat, sedentary, and less of a physical threat.”

The science does not deliver the outcome you want

Mouse studies in germ-free animals showed that microbiota from obese donors can increase energy harvest and adiposity compared with lean-donor microbiota. That is the origin of the idea. Human evidence is far weaker.

Randomized trials of fecal microbiota transplant (FMT) from lean donors into people with obesity have generally failed to produce meaningful, sustained weight loss. Microbiome composition can change; body weight and metabolic markers often do not, or the effects are small and inconsistent. Diet and the existing gut environment usually dominate. A 2025 Nature paper found diet outperformed microbial transplant for microbiome recovery. Human guts are already colonized, not sterile like lab mice, so engraftment is variable and effects unpredictable.

It is not a ...

post photo preview
August 28, 2026
Pfizer struggles to answer

Some in Australia are brilliant. Malcolm Roberts Investigates Pfizer over Covid vaccine.

Holiday break is over back to work tonight

Tonight I'll start double posting until I've caught up.

post photo preview
Mismanagement caused Dyke failure
November 18th

Mismanagement caused Dyke failure

The St. Elizabeth’s Flood of 18–19 November 1421 (Dutch: Sint-Elisabethsvloed) was a major storm-surge disaster in the Low Countries that permanently transformed the landscape of what is now the southwestern Netherlands. It is named for the feast day of St. Elizabeth of Hungary (then observed on 19 November).

Before: The Grote Waard and Vulnerability

The main area affected was the Grote (or Zuid-Hollandse) Waard, a large, prosperous polder of reclaimed farmland between Dordrecht, Geertruidenberg, and Heusden. It had been protected by dikes since the late 13th century (roughly completed around 1283). By 1421 the land surface had subsided below mean sea level because of drainage for agriculture and extensive peat digging (used for fuel and salt extraction). Deep “salt wells” dug close to the dikes further weakened the defences.

Politically, the County of Holland was convulsed by the Hook and Cod wars (Hoekse en Kabeljauwse twisten), a long series of factional conflicts that ran from the mid-14th century into the late 15th. In the early 15th century the struggle centred on the succession of Countess Jacoba (Jacqueline) of Bavaria. The Hooks generally supported her claims; the Cods backed her uncle John of Bavaria (“John the Pitiless”). Resources that should have gone to dike maintenance were diverted to war. Towns such as Dordrecht (Cod stronghold) and Geertruidenberg (often Hook-aligned) were frequently at odds; Dordrecht forces had attacked Geertruidenberg in 1420. A local dispute over salt extraction involving Jacob van Abcoude (Lord of Putten and Strijen) was only nominally settled weeks before the flood, with a finding that the wells did not endanger the dikes—an assessment soon proved disastrously wrong.

There had already been a major St. Elizabeth’s flood in 1404 that hit Flanders, Zeeland, and parts of Holland.

The Flood Itself

On the night of 18–19 November 1421 a powerful extratropical cyclone drove a storm surge up the rivers from the North Sea. Dikes broke (notably near Broek / Wieldrecht on the southwestern side of the Grote Waard). Water poured into the low-lying polder. Further failures followed in the following weeks and years (including a break on the Merwede side in early 1422 linked to ice jams and high river discharge). The flood separated Dordrecht and Geertruidenberg and inundated large parts of Holland, Zeeland, and Flanders.

Death toll and villages: Contemporary chronicles (notably the Chronicon Tielense) speak of about 2,000 deaths across the wider storm-affected region. Later legend inflated this to 10,000 or even 100,000 and claimed 72 villages were swallowed. Modern historians (including Jan Buisman and later geographers) regard the higher figures as myth-making. The Grote Waard itself contained fewer than 30 villages and a total population of roughly 20,000–22,000. Realistic estimates for the disaster are in the low thousands of deaths at most, with many people able to flee; some analyses suggest the immediate toll in the Waard itself may have been lower still. Roughly two dozen settlements became permanently uninhabitable.

A famous local legend (appearing in art by the 1490s) tells of a baby, later called Beatrix de Rijke (“Beatrix the Rich/Lucky”), who floated to safety in a cradle kept balanced by a cat. She was said to have been rescued near Dordrecht, raised at the city’s expense, and later married. The story is almost certainly folkloric, but the cradle-and-cat motif appears on surviving altar panels of the flood.

Aftermath and Landscape Transformation

Attempts to repair the dikes were half-hearted and repeatedly frustrated by continued political discord. Further breaches in 1424 finished the permanent loss of most of the Grote Waard. Large parts remained under water for decades; some land was never fully reclaimed. The inundated area evolved into a freshwater tidal delta of creeks, islands, and reed beds—the Biesbosch (roughly “forest of rushes”), now a national park. Reclaimed or surviving areas include the island of Dordrecht, the Hoeksche Waard, and parts of northwestern North Brabant around Geertruidenberg.

The flood permanently altered river courses and turned Dordrecht into an island. It also entered Dutch collective memory as one of the great water disasters (alongside the 1953 North Sea flood), inspiring chronicles, maps, altarpieces, and later Romantic paintings. The exaggerated numbers and the Beatrix legend helped turn a serious but not apocalyptic event into a near-biblical catastrophe in popular telling.

Significant Figures and Context

  • Jacoba of Bavaria (1401–1436): Countess of Holland, Zeeland, and Hainaut. Her contested succession and the Hook–Cod civil wars created the political instability that contributed to neglected defences. She was in England at the time of the flood.
  • John of Bavaria (“John the Pitiless”): Her uncle and rival, supported by the Cod faction; controlled key towns including Dordrecht.
  • Local lords and officials (e.g., Jacob van Abcoude) whose decisions on peat/salt extraction and dike upkeep had direct consequences.
  • Anonymous chroniclers (especially the Tiel chronicle) who provide the earliest relatively sober casualty figures.

In short, the 1421 flood was not caused by an unprecedented “superstorm” alone, but by the interaction of a severe North Sea storm surge with a landscape already compromised by subsidence, peat digging, and decades of civil war that had starved the dikes of maintenance. Its most lasting legacy is the Biesbosch wetlands and the enduring Dutch awareness of the vulnerability of low-lying land.

= November 18th

These events are associated with November 18.

Here is context on the major ones from your list:

Early Christian and Late Roman Era

  • 326 – Consecration of Old St. Peter’s Basilica: Emperor Constantine ordered a large basilica built over the traditional site of St. Peter’s tomb (and parts of Nero’s Circus) on Vatican Hill. Pope Sylvester I consecrated it on this date. It stood for about 1,200 years as a major pilgrimage site and the site of papal coronations (including Charlemagne’s in 800) before being largely demolished for the current basilica.

  • 401 – Visigoths under Alaric I cross the Alps: Alaric led the Visigoths into northern Italy. This was an early stage in the series of Gothic movements that culminated in the sack of Rome in 410, a symbolic blow to the Western Roman Empire. Roman general Stilicho later defeated him at Pollentia (402), but the pressure continued.

High Middle Ages: Papacy, Crusades, and Power Struggles

  • 1095 – Council of Clermont begins: Called by Pope Urban II, it ran roughly 18–28 November in Clermont (Auvergne). After dealing with reform issues (clerical celibacy, simony, Truce of God, excommunication of King Philip I of France), Urban’s speech on 27 November called for an armed pilgrimage to aid Eastern Christians and recover Jerusalem. This launched the First Crusade. “Deus vult!” (“God wills it!”) became the cry.

  • 1180 – Philip II (Philip Augustus) becomes king of France: He succeeded his father Louis VII (who had already crowned him co-king in 1179). Philip greatly expanded and centralized royal power, reconquering much of the Angevin territories held by the English kings and helping turn the Capetian monarchy into a stronger state.

  • 1302 – Pope Boniface VIII issues the bull Unam sanctam: Issued during his conflict with Philip IV of France, it declared that submission to the Roman pontiff is necessary for salvation and asserted the superiority of spiritual over temporal power (using the “two swords” imagery). It is the strongest medieval statement of papal hierocracy; the original is lost but it entered canon law. The dispute soon led to the outrage at Anagni (1303) and contributed to the move of the papacy to Avignon.

Other papal actions on this date include the election of Antipope Sylvester IV (1105), Innocent III’s excommunication of Emperor Otto IV (1210), and Martin IV’s excommunication of Peter III of Aragon (1282).

Late Middle Ages and Early Modern

  • 1421 – St. Elizabeth’s Flood: On the night of 18–19 November (named for the feast of St. Elizabeth of Hungary, then 19 November), a severe North Sea storm broke dikes in the Grote Waard (Netherlands). Dozens of villages were flooded; traditional accounts cite ~10,000 deaths and 72 villages lost, though modern estimates are often lower (around 2,000 deaths and fewer villages). Much of the land remained flooded for decades and helped shape the Biesbosch wetlands. Poor dike maintenance amid the Hook and Cod wars was a contributing factor.

  • 1493 – Columbus sights Puerto Rico: On his second voyage, the fleet sighted the island (known to the Taíno as Borinquen) around 17–19 November. Columbus named it San Juan Bautista. He made landfall on the northwest coast (near present-day Aguadilla/Añasco area) and stayed briefly before sailing on to Hispaniola.

  • 1626 – Consecration of the present St. Peter’s Basilica: Pope Urban VIII consecrated the rebuilt basilica exactly 1,300 years after the traditional date of the original. Construction had begun in 1506 under Julius II; major architects included Bramante, Raphael, and Michelangelo (who designed the dome). It remains the largest church in Christendom and the symbolic heart of Catholicism.

Later Events

  • 1730: The future Frederick II of Prussia (Frederick the Great) was released from confinement after a royal pardon.
  • 1760: The rebuilt debtors’ prison at the Castellania in Valletta, Malta, received its first prisoners.

These dates illustrate recurring themes of papal authority, church–state conflict, migration and conquest, and the long continuity of Christian sites in Rome. The two St. Peter’s consecrations (326 and 1626) on the same calendar day are especially striking.

Read full Article
post photo preview
The birth of Protestant Work Ethic
November 17th

The birth of Protestant Work Ethic

17 November 1558 marked the death of Mary I and the immediate accession of her half-sister Elizabeth I, ending the brief Catholic restoration under Mary and beginning the long Elizabethan era (1558–1603).

Before 1558: The Path to the Transition

Mary I (born 18 February 1516) was the only surviving child of Henry VIII and his first wife, Catherine of Aragon. After Henry’s break with Rome and the 1533 marriage to Anne Boleyn, Mary was declared illegitimate and suffered years of pressure and isolation. Anne Boleyn’s daughter Elizabeth (born 7 September 1533) was likewise declared illegitimate after Anne’s execution in 1536, though Henry’s 1544 Third Succession Act restored both daughters to the line of succession after their younger half-brother Edward.

Edward VI (reigned 1547–1553) was raised Protestant and died at 15 without heirs. His attempted diversion of the crown to the Protestant Lady Jane Grey collapsed within days; Mary, with strong popular and noble support, entered London and was proclaimed queen in July 1553. She was crowned in October 1553.

Mary’s reign was defined by three interlocking policies:

  • Restoration of Catholicism, including the repeal of Edwardian Protestant legislation and reconciliation with Rome under Cardinal Reginald Pole (appointed papal legate and Archbishop of Canterbury).
  • Marriage in July 1554 to Philip of Spain (later Philip II), making her queen consort of Spain from 1556. The marriage was deeply unpopular and sparked Wyatt’s Rebellion in early 1554, in which Elizabeth was implicated, imprisoned in the Tower of London, and later held under house arrest. No conclusive evidence of treason was produced, and she was released.
  • Persecution of Protestants. Roughly 280 people were burned at the stake (including bishops Hugh Latimer and Nicholas Ridley, and Archbishop Thomas Cranmer), earning Mary the later nickname “Bloody Mary.” Calais, England’s last Continental possession, was lost to France in early 1558.

Mary suffered false pregnancies and declining health. By late 1558 she was dying, probably of cancer. She had reluctantly accepted that the succession must pass to Elizabeth (the only viable heir under Henry VIII’s will), formally acknowledging her on or around 6 November. Philip II’s ambassador, the Count of Feria, was at court reporting on the situation. Mary died quietly at St James’s Palace on 17 November 1558, aged 42.

The Accession Day Itself

Elizabeth, then 25, was at Hatfield House. She was proclaimed queen the same day by the Lords and Commons assembled at Whitehall. Contemporary accounts note that she received the news with expressions of sorrow for her sister while immediately beginning to govern. 17 November later became Accession Day (or Queen’s Day), celebrated annually with bells, sermons, pageants, and (in later years) military reviews as a Protestant patriotic festival.

After 1558: The Elizabethan Settlement and Key Figures

Elizabeth moved quickly to reverse the Marian Catholic restoration. The 1559 Acts of Supremacy and Uniformity re-established a moderate Protestant Church of England with the queen as Supreme Governor, a revised Book of Common Prayer, and a broad church that could accommodate a range of beliefs while excluding open Catholicism and more radical Puritanism. She was crowned on 15 January 1559.

Central figures in the early years included:

  • William Cecil (later Lord Burghley): Principal Secretary from the outset and Elizabeth’s most trusted minister for nearly the entire reign.
  • Robert Dudley (later Earl of Leicester): Childhood friend, favourite, and persistent suitor; a major political and military figure.
  • Matthew Parker: First Archbishop of Canterbury under Elizabeth, who helped shape the settlement.
  • Nicholas Bacon and other privy councillors who formed a relatively stable early government.

Longer-term challenges and figures included the threat of Catholic succession (especially from Mary, Queen of Scots, who fled to England in 1568 and was eventually executed in 1587), the Spanish Armada of 1588 under Philip II, and the rise of a distinctive Elizabethan culture associated with figures such as Francis Drake, Walter Raleigh, and (later) William Shakespeare. The religious settlement proved durable enough to outlast the queen, though tensions with both Catholics and Puritans continued.

In short, Mary’s death closed a short, polarising Catholic interlude dominated by her Spanish marriage and the burnings, while Elizabeth’s accession launched a 44-year reign that defined a moderate Protestant England, survived major foreign and domestic threats, and is still remembered as a cultural high point.

= November 17th

These events cluster around mid-November in various years (often traditionally listed near 15–17 November). Here is context for each:

474 – Death of Emperor Leo II and sole rule by Zeno.
Leo II (c. 467–November 474), the young grandson of Leo I, had become co-emperor in late 473 and sole emperor after Leo I’s death in January 474. His father Zeno (an Isaurian general married to Leo I’s daughter Ariadne) was made co-emperor shortly afterward because the child was too young to rule effectively. Leo II died in Constantinople at about age 7 after roughly ten months as emperor. Contemporary sources give dates around early-to-mid November (or possibly into December, depending on the chronicler); no contemporary evidence supports poisoning, and high childhood mortality makes a natural death likely. Zeno thereby became sole Eastern Roman (Byzantine) emperor. His rule was immediately challenged by a coup from Verina’s brother Basiliscus in 475, but Zeno recovered the throne and held it until 491.

794 – Emperor Kanmu moves the capital from Nara to Kyoto.
Emperor Kanmu (Kammu, reigned 781–806) had already shifted the capital from Nara (Heijō-kyō) to Nagaoka-kyō in 784, partly to reduce the political influence of powerful Nara Buddhist monasteries. After problems at Nagaoka (including assassination of a key advisor, floods, and other ill omens), he relocated again in 794 to the newly planned Heian-kyō (“Capital of Peace and Tranquility”), modern Kyoto. Traditional dating places the emperor’s ceremonial move and the formal start of the Heian period around 17 November 794. The city was laid out on a Chinese-inspired grid and remained Japan’s imperial capital for more than a thousand years. Kanmu also expanded imperial authority in the north against the Emishi and supported the introduction of Tendai and Shingon Buddhism.

887 – Deposition of Charles the Fat; election of Arnulf of Carinthia.
In November 887 (sources cite an assembly at Frankfurt or nearby Tribur), East Frankish magnates deposed the ineffective Emperor Charles III “the Fat,” the last Carolingian to rule a reunited Frankish empire. His illegitimate nephew Arnulf of Carinthia (son of Carloman of Bavaria) was elected king of the East Frankish Kingdom. Charles yielded without major fighting and died early in 888. The event accelerated the permanent fragmentation of the Carolingian empire: West Francia, Burgundy, and Italy chose their own rulers. Arnulf later defeated Vikings decisively and briefly claimed the imperial title.

1183 – Battle of Mizushima.
On or about 17 November 1183, during the Genpei War (the Taira–Minamoto civil war), a naval action occurred off Mizushima in Bitchū Province (near modern Kurashiki/Okayama). Minamoto forces under commanders linked to Minamoto no Yoshinaka tried to cross the Inland Sea toward the Taira base at Yashima. The Taira (led by figures including Taira no Tomomori, Shigehira, and Noritsune) lashed their ships together with planks to form a fighting platform, used archers effectively, fought hand-to-hand, and even brought horses ashore to finish the rout. It was a clear Taira victory that checked Yoshinaka’s momentum. (Some accounts mention an annular solar eclipse coinciding with the fighting.)

1292 – John Balliol becomes King of Scotland.
After the death of Margaret, the Maid of Norway, left Scotland without a clear heir, the “Great Cause” succession dispute was arbitrated by Edward I of England. On 17 November 1292 at Berwick, the auditors (under Edward’s influence) awarded the crown to John Balliol (c. 1249–1314), whose claim through the female line from David I was judged superior on primogeniture. He was inaugurated at Scone on 30 November (St Andrew’s Day) and did homage to Edward. Edward treated Scotland as a vassal kingdom; Balliol’s weak reign collapsed in 1296 when Edward invaded, deposed him, and took the Stone of Destiny. Balliol later lived in exile in France.

1405 – Sharif ul-Hāshim establishes the Sultanate of Sulu.
Traditional dating places the founding of the Sultanate of Sulu on 17 November 1405 by Sharif ul-Hāshim (Sharif Abubakar Abirin Al-Hashmi), a Johor-born (or Arab-descended) Sunni scholar and explorer. He married a local princess (Dayang-dayang Paramisuli), introduced Islamic institutions and a Quran-based law code (the Diwan), and became the first sultan. The sultanate controlled the Sulu Archipelago, parts of Mindanao, Palawan, and later areas of northern Borneo. (Some accounts give an alternative founding year of c. 1457.) It remained an independent Muslim polity into the late 19th/early 20th century.

1511 – Treaty of Westminster between Henry VIII and Ferdinand II of Aragon.
In the context of the War of the League of Cambrai and the emerging Holy League against France, Henry VIII entered an alliance. On or about 17 November 1511 at Westminster, a treaty of mutual aid against France was concluded with Ferdinand II of Aragon (Henry’s father-in-law via Catherine of Aragon). It supported joint operations (including an eventual English expedition aimed at recovering Guienne/Aquitaine) and committed both to the papal-led anti-French coalition. It formed part of the wider diplomatic realignment of 1511–13 that led to English military involvement on the Continent.

1558 – Death of Mary I; accession of Elizabeth I (start of the Elizabethan era).
Mary I (daughter of Henry VIII and Catherine of Aragon) died on 17 November 1558 at St James’s Palace, aged 42, after a short and troubled reign marked by the restoration of Catholicism, the Spanish marriage to Philip II, and the persecution of Protestants. With no child, she was succeeded by her Protestant half-sister Elizabeth I (daughter of Anne Boleyn), then 25. Elizabeth was proclaimed the same day. The transition ended the brief Catholic restoration and opened the long Elizabethan reign (1558–1603), which re-established a moderate Protestant settlement and became a golden age of English culture and power. 17 November was later celebrated as Accession Day.

1603 – Sir Walter Raleigh’s trial for treason.
On 17 November 1603 at Winchester (moved from London because of plague), the Elizabethan courtier, explorer, and writer Sir Walter Raleigh was tried for high treason before a special commission. He was accused of involvement in the “Main Plot” to replace the new King James I with Arabella Stuart, involving Spanish money and Lord Cobham. The prosecution (led by Attorney-General Sir Edward Coke) relied heavily on Cobham’s statements; Raleigh had no counsel and limited rights to confront witnesses. He was convicted after a short jury deliberation and sentenced to death, but James reprieved him. Raleigh spent years in the Tower, was released for a final (failed) Guiana voyage, and was finally executed in 1618.

1777 – Articles of Confederation submitted to the states.
After months of debate, the Continental Congress adopted the Articles of Confederation on 15 November 1777 and submitted them to the thirteen states for ratification (with a covering letter dated around 17 November). This was the first constitution of the United States, creating a loose “league of friendship” of sovereign states with a weak central Congress. Unanimous state ratification was required; disputes over western land claims (especially Maryland’s holdout) delayed final ratification until 1 March 1781. The Articles governed the new nation through the end of the Revolutionary War and the early Confederation period until replaced by the 1787 Constitution.

1796 – Battle of the Bridge of Arcole.
From 15–17 November 1796, during the War of the First Coalition and Napoleon’s Italian Campaign, French forces under General Napoleon Bonaparte defeated an Austrian army under József Alvinczi near the bridge over the Alpone at Arcole (southeast of Verona). The fight was part of the third Austrian attempt to relieve the besieged fortress of Mantua. Fighting was fierce around the causeway and bridge; legend and contemporary propaganda emphasize Napoleon seizing a tricolor and leading charges (though the bridge was not decisively crossed on the first day, and the battle was a hard-won, multi-day engagement). The French victory forced Alvinczi to withdraw, preserved the Mantua siege, and boosted Bonaparte’s reputation. It was later celebrated in paintings (notably Horace Vernet’s) as a heroic moment.

These episodes span the late Roman/Byzantine world, medieval Europe and Japan, the early modern period, and the American and French Revolutions, illustrating shifts in imperial succession, capital relocation, the breakup of Carolingian power, clan warfare in Japan, Scottish-English relations, Islamic state formation in Southeast Asia, Tudor succession, English constitutional foundations, and Revolutionary warfare.

 

Read full Article
November 14, 2026
post photo preview
The Guillotine was too slow?
November 16th

The Guillotine was too slow?

The Drownings at Nantes (noyades de Nantes) were a series of mass executions by drowning carried out in the Loire River at Nantes, France, from mid-November 1793 to late February 1794. They occurred during the Reign of Terror as part of the Republican effort to crush the War in the Vendée (the Catholic and Royalist uprising in western France).

Before the Drownings

By late 1793 the Vendée rebellion had produced large numbers of prisoners. Nantes’s jails (including the Bouffay, the Coffee Warehouse/Entrepôt, and floating prison ships) were overcrowded with refractory (non-juring) Catholic clergy, Vendéan combatants and civilians, suspected royalists, and others arrested under the Law of Suspects (17 September 1793). Disease (especially typhus) and food shortages were acute.

Jean-Baptiste Carrier (1756–1794), a Montagnard/Jacobin deputy from the Cantal to the National Convention and member of the Cordeliers and Jacobin clubs, was sent as representative-on-mission to Brittany and then to Nantes (arriving around mid-October 1793). The Committee of Public Safety charged him with restoring order, securing supplies, and suppressing counter-revolution. He reorganized the local Revolutionary Committee of Nantes, established or reinforced a revolutionary tribunal, and relied on radical local forces, especially the Compagnie Marat (Marat Company).

Prisons were already full when Carrier arrived. Earlier methods (shootings, guillotine) could not keep pace with arrivals. Carrier and his subordinates began planning mass disposal of prisoners; he referred to drowning as “vertical deportation” or the “national bathtub.”

The Drownings and Key Figures

The first major operation took place on the night of 16–17 November 1793 (26 Brumaire Year II). Roughly 90–160 refractory priests (held for months after refusing the oath to the Civil Constitution of the Clergy) were transferred onto specially modified flat-bottomed barges (gabares or sapines) with openings cut in the hulls. These were taken into the Loire (near the Sécherie or toward Chantenay) and sunk. A few survivors were later recovered and re-executed. Guillaume Lamberty (or Lambertye; 1754–1794), an adjutant-general and former carriage-maker whom Carrier made his close lieutenant, directed this first drowning, assisted by men from the Compagnie Marat and others such as Fouquet.

Subsequent operations followed a similar pattern:

  • Further drownings of priests (including groups brought from Angers).
  • Larger “Bouffay” and other night-time operations in December 1793 that included hundreds of mixed prisoners (Vendéans, civilians, women, and children).
  • Later “galiote” drownings into January–February 1794 using larger vessels.

Bodies often washed ashore or floated visibly, drawing local attention. Estimates of total drowned range from about 1,800 to 4,800–5,000 (some higher contemporary or later claims exist; modern scholarship typically clusters in the 1,800–4,800 range for the noyades themselves). Additional thousands died from shootings (including at the Gigant quarry), starvation, or disease in the prisons. Carrier and the Nantes committee also ordered other repressive measures. The “republican marriages” (tying naked male and female prisoners together before drowning) are mentioned in some accounts but are often treated by historians as exaggerated or propagandistic.

Key supporting figures included members of the Revolutionary Committee of Nantes (such as Jean-Jacques Goullin and others) and local radicals who supplied lists of victims and carried out the operations. Carrier’s actions were initially endorsed or tolerated by the Committee of Public Safety in Paris.

After the Drownings

Word of the scale of the killings reached Paris. Carrier was recalled in February 1794 (he left Nantes around 16 February). He continued to justify harsh measures against the Vendée and briefly held office in the Convention. After the fall of Robespierre on 9 Thermidor (27 July 1794), the Thermidorian reaction turned against the most extreme Terrorists. Carrier was arrested in early September 1794, tried by the Revolutionary Tribunal for mass murder (including the drownings and shootings of non-combatants), convicted, and guillotined in Paris on 16 December 1794. Lamberty was also arrested after Carrier’s departure, tried by a local commission, and executed in Nantes in April 1794 (officially on other charges, though his role in the drownings was well known).

The noyades became one of the most notorious symbols of the excesses of the Terror. Contemporary and later writers (including Gracchus Babeuf and historians such as Jules Michelet) condemned them; they continue to feature in accounts of revolutionary violence, the Vendée war, and the limits of the Terror. Exact victim counts remain debated because many operations were semi-clandestine and records incomplete, but the events are firmly attested by contemporary testimony, trial evidence, and local archives.

= November 16th

These are notable historical events traditionally associated with mid-November (most commonly listed under 16 November). Here is a concise account of each.

951 – Conquest of Chu by Southern Tang

During the Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms period, Emperor Li Jing of the Southern Tang sent an expeditionary force of about 10,000 men under the general Bian Hao against the neighbouring state of Chu (Ma Chu). Chu had been weakened by civil war among the ruling Ma brothers. Bian Hao accepted the surrender of the capital (Changsha/Tan Prefecture), the Ma ruling family was removed to the Southern Tang capital at Nanjing (Jinling), and the Chu kingdom was formally ended.

Southern Tang control proved fragile; local Chu generals soon rebelled and largely expelled the occupiers the following year. The campaign still marked a clear territorial expansion for Li Jing before later pressures from the Later Zhou and Song.

1272 – Edward becomes King of England while on Crusade

Prince Edward (later Edward I “Longshanks”) was in the Holy Land leading the Ninth Crusade when he received news of the death of his father, Henry III of England (16 November 1272). He therefore became king while still abroad.

Edward was in no hurry to return. He recovered from an assassination attempt (a poisoned dagger), travelled through Sicily, Italy, Gascony and France, and only reached England in 1274, where he was crowned at Westminster Abbey on 19 August. The Ninth Crusade is generally regarded as the last major Western expedition to the Holy Land before the final fall of Acre in 1291.

1491 – Auto-da-fé of the Holy Child of La Guardia

On 16 November 1491 an auto-da-fé was held in the Brasero de la Dehesa outside Ávila. It concluded the case of the “Holy Child of La Guardia,” a blood-libel accusation that a group of Jews and conversos had kidnapped and ritually murdered a Christian child (whose heart was supposedly used for sorcery).

Several Jews and conversos were burned (sources commonly cite around six conversos and two or three Jews). No body was ever found, the confessions were obtained under torture, and the details were inconsistent. The case occurred just months before the 1492 Alhambra Decree expelling the Jews from Spain and is widely regarded by historians as one of the most infamous Spanish blood libels.

1532 – Capture of Atahualpa at Cajamarca

On 16 November 1532 Francisco Pizarro and a force of roughly 168 Spanish soldiers and auxiliaries ambushed the Inca emperor Atahualpa in the plaza of Cajamarca (in present-day Peru). Atahualpa had entered the town with a large, largely unarmed retinue while tens of thousands of his troops camped nearby.

The Spanish opened fire with guns and cannons, charged with cavalry, and killed thousands of attendants in a short, one-sided action. Atahualpa was seized alive. The capture paralysed Inca resistance, opened the way for the Spanish conquest of the Inca Empire, and led (after a massive gold-and-silver ransom) to Atahualpa’s execution in 1533.

1776 – Capture of Fort Washington

British and Hessian forces under General William Howe attacked Fort Washington (near the northern end of Manhattan) on 16 November 1776. After fighting on the outer lines, the American garrison under Colonel Robert Magaw surrendered.

The Patriots lost roughly 2,800 men as prisoners (plus killed and wounded). Most of the prisoners were confined on British prison ships in New York harbour, where disease and harsh conditions killed a large majority. It was one of the worst American defeats of the Revolutionary War and left the British in control of Manhattan.

1776 – “First Salute” by the Dutch (St. Eustatius)

On the same day (16 November 1776) the American brig Andrew Doria, flying the Grand Union flag, entered the harbour of the Dutch Caribbean island of St. Eustatius. Governor Johannes de Graaff ordered Fort Oranje to return the ship’s salute with an 11-gun volley.

This is widely remembered as the First Salute—the first formal acknowledgement of American sovereignty by an official of a foreign power. Formal diplomatic recognition by the Dutch Republic itself came later (1782), but the gesture was treated by Britain as a provocative act and contributed to rising Anglo-Dutch tensions.

1793 – Drownings at Nantes begin

During the Reign of Terror, the Convention’s representative-on-mission Jean-Baptiste Carrier began the mass drownings (noyades) in Nantes. On the night of 16 November 1793 the first large group—approximately 90–160 refractory (non-juring) Catholic priests—was loaded onto barges and sunk in the Loire.

Carrier called the method “the national bathtub.” The drownings continued until early 1794 and claimed thousands of victims (estimates range from roughly 1,800 to 4,800 or more), including priests, nuns, Vendéan prisoners, and other “suspects.” They remain one of the most notorious atrocities of the Revolution.

1797 – Accession of Frederick William III of Prussia

On 16 November 1797 the Prussian heir apparent became King of Prussia as Frederick William III upon the death of his father, Frederick William II. He reigned until 1840.

Early in his reign he pursued neutrality, austerity, and limited reform. Prussia later entered the Napoleonic Wars (disastrously in 1806), then played a major role in the final coalition that defeated Napoleon. His queen, Louise of Mecklenburg-Strelitz, was especially popular and became a symbol of Prussian resistance and recovery.

These episodes range from dynastic conquest and crusading kingship to blood libel, the fall of the Inca Empire, the American Revolution, revolutionary terror, and the start of a long Prussian reign.

Read full Article
See More
Available on mobile and TV devices
google store google store app store app store
google store google store app tv store app tv store amazon store amazon store roku store roku store
Powered by Locals