VoiceDDB
Politics • Culture • News
The Brief, Bright Flame of James A. Garfield
Reform, Resolve, and a Nation’s Loss
June 29, 2026
post photo preview

The Brief, Bright Flame of James A. Garfield: Reform, Resolve, and a Nation’s Loss

The 1876 presidential election delivered Rutherford B. Hayes to the White House through a bitterly contested compromise. In exchange for Southern Democratic acquiescence, federal troops withdrew from the South, effectively ending Reconstruction. State Republican governments collapsed, and the region solidified into a one-party Democratic stronghold. African Americans, newly freed and enfranchised, faced systematic isolation, disenfranchisement, and predation. Populism, it seemed, could accommodate such outcomes if it preserved a fragile peace.

James A. Garfield, the 20th President, represented a different Republican tradition. Elected in 1880, he entered office with greater discipline and vision than his predecessor. A Union veteran, scholar, and principled legislator, Garfield understood that the Republic’s strength depended on merit, integrity, and opportunity for all. In his short time in office—roughly 200 days—he moved decisively against the spoils system that bred corruption, particularly in the Post Office. He championed civil service reform, laying groundwork for the Pendleton Act that would follow his death. He appointed African Americans to prominent federal positions and advocated vigorously for civil rights and education, viewing an educated electorate as essential to a free and fair democracy.

Garfield’s vision was rooted in the Radical Republican commitment to the promises of emancipation. He saw the elevation of Black citizens not merely as moral duty but as national necessity—tying economic progress, political stability, and moral legitimacy together. His brief presidency signaled a potential renewal of Reconstruction-era ideals at a moment when many were ready to abandon them.

Then came the tragedy. On July 2, 1881, at a Washington train station, Charles J. Guiteau, a delusional office-seeker, shot Garfield twice from behind. Guiteau, born in Illinois to a Huguenot family, had a troubled path: academic struggles, involvement with a religious cult, failure as a lawyer, plagiarism in theology, and repeated, rejected pleas for patronage from Hayes and then Garfield. He harbored the fantasy that his meager support for Garfield’s campaign entitled him to a diplomatic post. When rebuffed—especially by Garfield’s opposition to the very corruption Guiteau embodied—he chose violence. He selected a pearl-handled revolver for its supposed historical appeal.

Garfield did not die immediately. The bullet wounds were serious but survivable with proper care. Instead, doctors repeatedly probed the wound with unsterilized hands and instruments—practices that would soon become obsolete under Listerian antisepsis. Infection set in, and after 80 agonizing days, Garfield succumbed on September 19, 1881. Guiteau’s later boast—“The doctors killed him; I only shot him”—contained a grim kernel of truth, though it did nothing to absolve him.

Guiteau’s trial featured one of the early high-profile attempts at an insanity defense in the United States. It failed. On June 30, 1882—nearly a year after the shooting—he was hanged. That morning he recited his own poem, “I am Going to the Lordy,” a childlike, repetitive hymn of delusional self-justification:

I am going to the Lordy, I am so glad... I saved my party and my land... But they have murdered me for it... Glory hallelujah! Glory hallelujah!

Guiteau was no coherent “right-wing extremist” in any modern ideological sense. He was a mentally unstable crank, a Stalwart Republican hanger-on driven by entitlement and grievance, not a principled ideologue. Labeling every disordered actor by contemporary political categories distorts more than it illuminates. His case highlighted vulnerabilities in the patronage system Garfield sought to reform and exposed gaps in medical knowledge and presidential security.

The assassination’s indirect legacies were notable. Efforts to cool Garfield’s sickroom spurred early developments in air conditioning for the U.S. Navy. Alexander Graham Bell, at the family’s request, improvised a metal detector in hopes of locating the bullet—though it was thwarted by the metal bed frame.

Garfield’s death was a profound loss. In an era of retreating federal commitment to civil rights, he stood as a bulwark for education, merit, and equality under law. His reforms and appointments pointed toward a more just Republic. The nation that mourned him soon passed civil service legislation in his name, but the fuller promise of his leadership—sustained federal protection for Black citizens and a professional, corruption-resistant government—would take generations to even partially fulfill.

James Garfield served too briefly, yet his example endures: a scholar-president who believed in disciplined governance, civil rights as national strength, and the duty to confront corruption even at personal cost. In remembering him, we confront both the fragility of progress and the enduring need for leaders willing to defend the Republic’s highest ideals against complacency and chaos alike.

community logo
Join the VoiceDDB Community
To read more articles like this, sign up and join my community today
0
What else you may like…
Videos
Posts
Articles
00:01:07
November 27, 2022
Jingle Bell Rock

Jingle bell, jingle bell, jingle bell rock
Jingle bells swing and jingle bells ring
Snowin' and blowin' up bushels of fun
Now the jingle hop has begun

Jingle bell, jingle bell, jingle bell rock
Jingle bells chime in jingle bell time
Dancin' and prancin' in Jingle Bell Square
In the frosty air

What a bright time, it's the right time
To rock the night away
Jingle bell time is a swell time
To go glidin' in a one-horse sleigh

Giddy-up jingle horse, pick up your feet
Jingle around the clock
Mix and a-mingle in the jinglin' feet
That's the jingle bell rock

Jingle bell, jingle bell, jingle bell rock
Jingle bell chime in jingle bell time
Dancin' and prancin' in Jingle Bell Square
In the frosty air

What a bright time, it's the right time
To rock the night away
Jingle bell time is a swell time
To go glidin' in a one-horse sleigh

Giddy-up jingle horse, pick up your feet
Jingle around the clock
Mix and a-mingle in the jinglin' feet
That's the jingle bell
That's the jingle bell
That's the jingle...

00:02:04
September 01, 2021
Intro to Locals for the Conservative Voice

David Daniel Ball calls himself the Conservative Voice.

I'm a teacher with three decades experience teaching math to high school kids.I also work with first graders and kids in between first grade and high school. I know the legends of why Hypatia's dad is remembered through his contribution to Math theory. And I know the legend of why followers of Godel had thought he had disproved God's existence.

I'm not a preacher, but I am a Christian who has written over 28 books all of which include some reference to my faith. Twelve blog books on world history and current affairs, detailing world events , births and marriages on each day of the year, organised by month. Twelve books on the background to and history of Bible Quotes. One Bible quote per day for a year. An intro to a science fiction series I'm planning, post apocalyptic cyber punk. An autobiography with short story collections.

I'm known in Australia for my failure as a whistleblower over the negligence death of a school boy. ...

00:01:50
September 04, 2026
Should violent criminals be made fat? Grok says 'no'

No. Transferring gut bacteria from an obese person into a violent criminal is not a reliable, ethical, or effective way to make them “fat, sedentary, and less of a physical threat.”

The science does not deliver the outcome you want

Mouse studies in germ-free animals showed that microbiota from obese donors can increase energy harvest and adiposity compared with lean-donor microbiota. That is the origin of the idea. Human evidence is far weaker.

Randomized trials of fecal microbiota transplant (FMT) from lean donors into people with obesity have generally failed to produce meaningful, sustained weight loss. Microbiome composition can change; body weight and metabolic markers often do not, or the effects are small and inconsistent. Diet and the existing gut environment usually dominate. A 2025 Nature paper found diet outperformed microbial transplant for microbiome recovery. Human guts are already colonized, not sterile like lab mice, so engraftment is variable and effects unpredictable.

It is not a ...

post photo preview
August 28, 2026
Pfizer struggles to answer

Some in Australia are brilliant. Malcolm Roberts Investigates Pfizer over Covid vaccine.

Holiday break is over back to work tonight

Tonight I'll start double posting until I've caught up.

post photo preview
How FBI took 5 years to catch the wrong guy
Pipe bombs of Jan 6th 2021 inside job

How FBI took 5 years to catch the wrong guy

Pipe bombs of Jan 6th 2021 inside job

That video is a commentary interview, not a court finding. It is a Viva Frei stream from about 2–3 October 2026, hosted with former FBI agent Kyle Seraphin, under a title close to “Did the FBI Coerce a FALSE CONFESSION Out of The Alleged Jan. 6 Pipe Bomber?” (the “FALS” spelling is a typo in the share text). The YouTube link circulating with that title is youtu.be/cQn9_7dKRzw. A related version also ran on Rumble as “How to Coerce a False Confession.”

The video’s claim is that the FBI took almost five years to name Brian Cole Jr., and that he had not been hiding from the surveillance the Bureau already had.

Devices were placed the night of 5 January 2021. Cole was arrested on the morning of 4 December 2025, walking to a 7-Eleven near the Woodbridge, Virginia home where he lived with his parents. That is four years and eleven months. On the show, former FBI agent Kyle Seraphin treats that gap as the point: no flight, no new identity, no move. Same house, same daily routine, neighborhood walks with his dog, work tied to his father’s bail-bond business and deliveries. The guest’s line is that this man “evaded” the FBI for five years while living in his parents’ house, in plain sight of the same phone, car, and purchase records the Bureau later called decisive.

What the video says the interview shows:

  • The session ran about four hours on the day of the arrest, starting from a gunpoint stop on the way to the store, before he was taken to a judge the lawyers say was minutes away.
  • He denied being the hooded figure on the video. Agents told him lying to federal agents was another crime and that more denials would make it worse. After a pause he said “yes.”
  • They warned they could bring his family in and put them through the same interview.
  • He was distressed on the recording: chills, gagging, repetitive speech the defense calls stimming. Agents wrapped him in a blanket.
  • A defense expert, Richard Leo, is cited for the claim that the tactics — guilt-presumptive questioning, evidence ploys, minimization and maximization, implied threats — are the kind shown to raise the risk of a false admission, especially in someone later diagnosed with level-1 autism.
  • The “yes,” on this telling, was not recognition of the video. He had just said he did not recognize the person. It was the product of being told that “no” was itself a crime, after which he began repeating the agents’ account.

Seraphin’s claim on the show is that this is how a false confession is produced, and that Cole does not match the hooded figure the FBI had on camera from the start.

=

For October 5th

The Catholic and Orthodox churches did not divide on one day. They grew apart for centuries, healed more than once, and only later treated the breach as permanent. The council of 869 is one of the early fractures, and it did not hold.

For the first centuries there was one church with several chief sees. Rome, Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch and Jerusalem were the five patriarchates. Rome had a primacy of honour as the see of Peter and Paul, and the only apostolic see in the West. Constantinople had the emperor, the court, and from the sixth century the title “ecumenical patriarch.” Greek in the East, Latin in the West, different liturgies, and two ideas of authority were already in place before anyone spoke of a schism. The East thought of Rome as the senior patriarch, whose voice mattered most in a council. The popes of the ninth century were already claiming a jurisdiction that could judge other patriarchs.

Photius sat in the middle of that argument. In 858 the emperor Michael III deposed Patriarch Ignatius and replaced him with Photius, a lay scholar and head of the imperial chancery. He was elected, tonsured and ordained through the grades to the patriarchate within about a week. Ignatius’s party appealed to Rome. Pope Nicholas I refused to recognise the appointment. Canon law, as Rome read it, did not allow a layman to be rushed to the highest see, and it did not allow an emperor to depose a patriarch and have Rome rubber-stamp the result.

The fight then moved to Bulgaria. Both Rome and Constantinople wanted the new Bulgarian church. Nicholas wrote to the Bulgars attacking Greek customs: married clergy, the leavened bread of the Eucharist, and other rites. Photius answered in 867 with a council in Constantinople that deposed and anathematised Nicholas and the Western church. The charge that lasted was the Filioque. The Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed says the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father. In Spain, and then more widely in the Latin West, churches had added “and from the Son” — Filioque — to stress the Son’s full divinity against Arianism. Rome itself adopted the addition later. Photius called the addition a corruption of the creed and a theological error. The East’s objection was twofold: that the Spirit proceeds from the Father alone, the Son being involved in the Spirit’s sending but not in his eternal origin; and that no one see had the right to alter a creed fixed by an ecumenical council.

That council of 867 did not last the year. Basil I murdered Michael III, took the throne, and restored Ignatius. Nicholas died in November 867. His successor, Adrian II, condemned Photius, and Basil called the council that opened in Constantinople on 5 October 869. It sat until 28 February 870. It restored Ignatius, anathematised Photius, burned the acts of the 867 synod, and issued 27 canons. The papal legates pressed for a clear submission to Roman judgment. Attendance was poor: about a dozen bishops at the opening, never more than about a hundred. The West later counted this as the Fourth Council of Constantinople and the eighth ecumenical council. The East never did.

It also failed on the ground. Ignatius died in 877. Photius became patriarch again, with Basil’s support, and Pope John VIII recognised him in return for concessions on Bulgaria and a promise not to press the Filioque quarrel. A much larger council in Constantinople in 879–80 rehabilitated Photius, annulled the council of 869–70, and was accepted at the time by John VIII’s legates. Rome later repudiated that acceptance. Photius died in communion with Rome, or near enough to it that the breach closed. The Orthodox Church venerates him as a saint. The Catholic Church does not count his rehabilitating council.

What survived was the pair of questions. Does the Spirit proceed from the Father and the Son, or from the Father alone? And is the pope the monarch of the whole church, or the first among patriarchs who cannot rewrite a council’s creed or depose an eastern bishop on his own? Those questions were quiet for long stretches. They were not settled.

The date everyone remembers is 16 July 1054. Patriarch Michael Cerularius had closed Latin churches in Constantinople and attacked Western rites, especially unleavened bread. Pope Leo IX sent Cardinal Humbert. Humbert was abrasive, Leo had in fact already died, and on 16 July Humbert laid a bull of excommunication on the altar of Hagia Sophia. It named Cerularius and his supporters, and it condemned the Greek doctrine of the Spirit, married priests, and leavened bread. Cerularius excommunicated the legates in return. The two bulls did not excommunicate whole churches. Most bishops, east and west, never heard of them. Communion had already been patchy; it continued, in places, afterwards.

The split became a fact in the crusading era. The massacre of Latins in Constantinople in 1182, and then the Fourth Crusade’s sack of the city in 1204, turned a quarrel of theologians and patriarchs into a wound ordinary people remembered. A Latin patriarch was set up in Constantinople. Reunion was signed at the Second Council of Lyon in 1274 and again at Florence in 1439, both times under political pressure — the second time with the Ottoman siege already in view. Neither union survived contact with the eastern clergy and people. After 1453 Constantinople was Ottoman, and Moscow came to call itself the Third Rome. The anathemas of 1054 were lifted by Pope Paul VI and Patriarch Athenagoras in 1965. That removed a symbol. It did not restore communion.

So the council of 869 matters as a rehearsal. A pope and an emperor deposed a patriarch; a thin council ratified it; a fuller council undid it; Rome and Constantinople kept different memories of which council had spoken for the church. The later schism grew from that disagreement about authority, from the Filioque, and from the political rupture of 1204, not from a single anathema in 869 or 1054.

=

These are the standard “on this day” entries for 5 October. A few of the ancient dates are calendar conversions, and one revolutionary claim is looser than the list makes it sound.

539 BC — Babylon falls to Cyrus. The Nabonidus Chronicle puts the entry into the city on the 16th of Tašrītu in the 17th year of Nabonidus. Sippar had fallen two days earlier without a fight; Nabonidus fled, then was taken when he returned. The man who entered was Ugbaru (Gobryas), governor of Gutium, with Cyrus’s army. Cyrus himself came in about a fortnight later, in Arahsamna. Parker and Dubberstein’s Babylonian chronology converts the 16th of Tašrītu to 12 October Julian, which is about 5–6 October on the proleptic Gregorian calendar — hence the date on modern lists. The Cyrus Cylinder presents the takeover as peaceful and as the choice of Marduk; Herodotus and the book of Daniel remember a festival night and a breached river defence. What is solid is the political result: the Neo-Babylonian empire ended, and Cyrus’s edict let the Judean exiles go home. That is the hinge Second Isaiah and the book of Ezra both hang on.

456 — the Suebi broken on the Órbigo. Theodoric II, king of the Visigoths, moved into Iberia on the orders of the short-lived western emperor Avitus. With him were Burgundian forces under Chilperic I and Gundioc, and Frankish contingents. On the river Urbicus (the Órbigo), near Astorga in Gallaecia, they defeated the Suebi under Rechiar. Rechiar was captured and later executed. Suebic power in the north-west did not vanish at once, but the battle ended their bid to dominate the peninsula and left the Visigoths as the coming power in Hispania.

610 — Heraclius crowned. Heraclius, son of the exarch of Africa, sailed on Constantinople against the usurper Phocas. The Excubitors deserted, the city opened, and Phocas was killed — by Heraclius’s own hand in some accounts, after the exchange “Is this how you have ruled?” / “And will you rule better?” On 5 October, in the chapel of St Stephen in the Great Palace, Patriarch Sergius crowned him, and he married Fabia, who took the name Eudocia. He inherited a wreck: Avars in the Balkans, Khosrow II already using Maurice’s murder as a pretext for war. Syria, Palestine and Egypt would fall; the True Cross would be carried off. Heraclius’s answer was personal command, a rebuilt army, and the campaign that ended at Nineveh in 627. The peace he won was brief. Within a decade the same provinces were lost again, this time to the Arabs.

816 — Louis the Pious crowned at Reims. Louis was already emperor. Charlemagne had crowned him co-emperor at Aachen on 11 September 813, and he had ruled alone since his father’s death in 814. Pope Stephen IV came north anyway. On Sunday 5 October, during Mass at Reims, Stephen anointed him and set on his head a crown said to have been Constantine’s. Ermengarde was crowned with him and hailed Augusta. Louis had prostrated himself before the pope. The act did not make him emperor; it reattached the imperial title to a papal coronation, which Charlemagne’s 813 ceremony had sidestepped. Reims became the place where French kings were crowned.

869 — the council that deposed Photius. The Fourth Council of Constantinople, counted in the West as the eighth ecumenical council, opened on 5 October 869 and sat until 28 February 870. Emperor Basil I and Pope Adrian II wanted Photius out. Photius, a lay scholar raised abruptly to the patriarchate in 858, had been deposed once, restored, and had anathematised Pope Nicholas I in 867. The council restored Ignatius, anathematised Photius, burned the acts of his 867 synod, and issued 27 canons. Attendance was thin — a dozen bishops at the start, never more than about a hundred. The East does not receive it. Photius was patriarch again from 877, and the council of 879–80, far better attended, rehabilitated him. This is one of the fractures that later hardened into the schism.

1143 — Portugal recognised at Zamora. On 5 October, at Zamora, with the papal legate Cardinal Guido de Vico present, Alfonso VII of León and Castile — who styled himself emperor of the Spains — acknowledged his cousin Afonso Henriques as king of Portugal. Afonso had already won the field against his mother at São Mamede in 1128 and had used the royal title after Ourique in 1139. The text of the treaty is lost. What survived is the political fact: the Leonese crown stopped contesting the title, and Afonso signed as rex Portugallensis. Full papal recognition waited until Alexander III’s bull Manifestis Probatum in 1179. Portugal still marks 5 October, though the modern national holiday is the republic of 1910, not Zamora.

1450 — Jews expelled from Lower Bavaria. Louis IX, Duke of Bavaria-Landshut, called Louis the Rich, ordered the Jews out of his part of Bavaria. This sits in the long fifteenth-century squeeze on German Jewish communities — debt cancellation dressed as piety, local expulsions before the larger ones of the 1490s. It was not the end of Jewish life in all Bavaria; Regensburg’s community lasted until 1519. It was a ducal clearance of Lower Bavaria.

1550 — Concepción founded. Pedro de Valdivia founded the city on 5 October 1550, at Penco on the Bay of Concepción, as a southern anchor of Spanish Chile against the Mapuche frontier. Earthquakes and Araucanian war forced later moves; the modern city stands inland of that first site. The date is the official foundation.

1582 — a day that did not happen. Pope Gregory XIII’s bull cut ten days from October so that the spring equinox, and therefore Easter, would fall where the Council of Nicaea had put it. In Italy, Spain, Portugal and the Polish–Lithuanian lands, 4 October was followed by 15 October. The 5th through the 14th do not exist in those countries for that year. France waited until December; Protestant states longer; Britain until 1752.

1607 — the knives and Paolo Sarpi. Sarpi, a Servite friar and Venice’s theological adviser in the Interdict fight with Paul V, was attacked on the night of 5 October as he came down the bridge by Santa Fosca toward his convent. Five men; fifteen thrusts by the count of holes in hat, hood and collar; three wounds that landed, one stiletto left in the cheekbone. He lived. Asked who had done it, he said Agnosco stylum Romanae Curiae — “I recognise the style of the Roman Curia,” with stilus also meaning dagger. The attackers fled toward the papal nuncio’s house and on to Rome. Venice gave him a safer lodging. He went back to his work on the history of the Council of Trent.

1665 — Kiel. Christian Albert, Duke of Holstein-Gottorp, founded the university on 5 October. It still bears his name: Christian-Albrechts-Universität.

1789 — the women march to Versailles. On the morning of 5 October, women from the Paris markets, after days of bread shortage and rumour, set off for Versailles. They wanted grain, and they wanted the king to sanction the August decrees and the Declaration of the Rights of Man. The National Guard followed under Lafayette, partly to lead the march and partly to keep it from becoming a sack. That night and the next morning the palace was invaded; two guards were killed. On the 6th Louis XVI agreed to move to Paris. The court came back to the Tuileries in the train of the crowd. The revolution ceased to be something that happened at a safe distance from the king.

1793 — the calendar, not a single act of abolition. Lists often say Christianity was disestablished in France on this day. What the Convention actually did on 5 October 1793 was accept Gilbert Romme’s scheme for a republican era beginning on 22 September 1792, the day the Republic had been proclaimed. The calendar itself was decreed on 24 October and backdated. Sunday disappeared; saints’ days were replaced by the names of plants, tools and weather; the aim was to take Christian time out of ordinary life. Dechristianisation was already a campaign — closed churches, the Cult of Reason, death for non-juring priests and those who hid them — not a statute passed on the 5th that ended the faith by decree. The Republican calendar lasted until 1806.

The day runs from a change of empire in Babylon to a change of calendar in Paris, with coronations, a council, a new kingdom and a failed killing in between.

Read full Article
post photo preview
Catholic Orthodox Schism
Shades of christianity

Catholic Orthodox Schism

Shades of christianity

The Catholic and Orthodox churches did not divide on one day. They grew apart for centuries, healed more than once, and only later treated the breach as permanent. The council of 869 is one of the early fractures, and it did not hold.

For the first centuries there was one church with several chief sees. Rome, Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch and Jerusalem were the five patriarchates. Rome had a primacy of honour as the see of Peter and Paul, and the only apostolic see in the West. Constantinople had the emperor, the court, and from the sixth century the title “ecumenical patriarch.” Greek in the East, Latin in the West, different liturgies, and two ideas of authority were already in place before anyone spoke of a schism. The East thought of Rome as the senior patriarch, whose voice mattered most in a council. The popes of the ninth century were already claiming a jurisdiction that could judge other patriarchs.

Photius sat in the middle of that argument. In 858 the emperor Michael III deposed Patriarch Ignatius and replaced him with Photius, a lay scholar and head of the imperial chancery. He was elected, tonsured and ordained through the grades to the patriarchate within about a week. Ignatius’s party appealed to Rome. Pope Nicholas I refused to recognise the appointment. Canon law, as Rome read it, did not allow a layman to be rushed to the highest see, and it did not allow an emperor to depose a patriarch and have Rome rubber-stamp the result.

The fight then moved to Bulgaria. Both Rome and Constantinople wanted the new Bulgarian church. Nicholas wrote to the Bulgars attacking Greek customs: married clergy, the leavened bread of the Eucharist, and other rites. Photius answered in 867 with a council in Constantinople that deposed and anathematised Nicholas and the Western church. The charge that lasted was the Filioque. The Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed says the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father. In Spain, and then more widely in the Latin West, churches had added “and from the Son” — Filioque — to stress the Son’s full divinity against Arianism. Rome itself adopted the addition later. Photius called the addition a corruption of the creed and a theological error. The East’s objection was twofold: that the Spirit proceeds from the Father alone, the Son being involved in the Spirit’s sending but not in his eternal origin; and that no one see had the right to alter a creed fixed by an ecumenical council.

That council of 867 did not last the year. Basil I murdered Michael III, took the throne, and restored Ignatius. Nicholas died in November 867. His successor, Adrian II, condemned Photius, and Basil called the council that opened in Constantinople on 5 October 869. It sat until 28 February 870. It restored Ignatius, anathematised Photius, burned the acts of the 867 synod, and issued 27 canons. The papal legates pressed for a clear submission to Roman judgment. Attendance was poor: about a dozen bishops at the opening, never more than about a hundred. The West later counted this as the Fourth Council of Constantinople and the eighth ecumenical council. The East never did.

It also failed on the ground. Ignatius died in 877. Photius became patriarch again, with Basil’s support, and Pope John VIII recognised him in return for concessions on Bulgaria and a promise not to press the Filioque quarrel. A much larger council in Constantinople in 879–80 rehabilitated Photius, annulled the council of 869–70, and was accepted at the time by John VIII’s legates. Rome later repudiated that acceptance. Photius died in communion with Rome, or near enough to it that the breach closed. The Orthodox Church venerates him as a saint. The Catholic Church does not count his rehabilitating council.

What survived was the pair of questions. Does the Spirit proceed from the Father and the Son, or from the Father alone? And is the pope the monarch of the whole church, or the first among patriarchs who cannot rewrite a council’s creed or depose an eastern bishop on his own? Those questions were quiet for long stretches. They were not settled.

The date everyone remembers is 16 July 1054. Patriarch Michael Cerularius had closed Latin churches in Constantinople and attacked Western rites, especially unleavened bread. Pope Leo IX sent Cardinal Humbert. Humbert was abrasive, Leo had in fact already died, and on 16 July Humbert laid a bull of excommunication on the altar of Hagia Sophia. It named Cerularius and his supporters, and it condemned the Greek doctrine of the Spirit, married priests, and leavened bread. Cerularius excommunicated the legates in return. The two bulls did not excommunicate whole churches. Most bishops, east and west, never heard of them. Communion had already been patchy; it continued, in places, afterwards.

The split became a fact in the crusading era. The massacre of Latins in Constantinople in 1182, and then the Fourth Crusade’s sack of the city in 1204, turned a quarrel of theologians and patriarchs into a wound ordinary people remembered. A Latin patriarch was set up in Constantinople. Reunion was signed at the Second Council of Lyon in 1274 and again at Florence in 1439, both times under political pressure — the second time with the Ottoman siege already in view. Neither union survived contact with the eastern clergy and people. After 1453 Constantinople was Ottoman, and Moscow came to call itself the Third Rome. The anathemas of 1054 were lifted by Pope Paul VI and Patriarch Athenagoras in 1965. That removed a symbol. It did not restore communion.

So the council of 869 matters as a rehearsal. A pope and an emperor deposed a patriarch; a thin council ratified it; a fuller council undid it; Rome and Constantinople kept different memories of which council had spoken for the church. The later schism grew from that disagreement about authority, from the Filioque, and from the political rupture of 1204, not from a single anathema in 869 or 1054.

=

These are the standard “on this day” entries for 5 October. A few of the ancient dates are calendar conversions, and one revolutionary claim is looser than the list makes it sound.

539 BC — Babylon falls to Cyrus. The Nabonidus Chronicle puts the entry into the city on the 16th of Tašrītu in the 17th year of Nabonidus. Sippar had fallen two days earlier without a fight; Nabonidus fled, then was taken when he returned. The man who entered was Ugbaru (Gobryas), governor of Gutium, with Cyrus’s army. Cyrus himself came in about a fortnight later, in Arahsamna. Parker and Dubberstein’s Babylonian chronology converts the 16th of Tašrītu to 12 October Julian, which is about 5–6 October on the proleptic Gregorian calendar — hence the date on modern lists. The Cyrus Cylinder presents the takeover as peaceful and as the choice of Marduk; Herodotus and the book of Daniel remember a festival night and a breached river defence. What is solid is the political result: the Neo-Babylonian empire ended, and Cyrus’s edict let the Judean exiles go home. That is the hinge Second Isaiah and the book of Ezra both hang on.

456 — the Suebi broken on the Órbigo. Theodoric II, king of the Visigoths, moved into Iberia on the orders of the short-lived western emperor Avitus. With him were Burgundian forces under Chilperic I and Gundioc, and Frankish contingents. On the river Urbicus (the Órbigo), near Astorga in Gallaecia, they defeated the Suebi under Rechiar. Rechiar was captured and later executed. Suebic power in the north-west did not vanish at once, but the battle ended their bid to dominate the peninsula and left the Visigoths as the coming power in Hispania.

610 — Heraclius crowned. Heraclius, son of the exarch of Africa, sailed on Constantinople against the usurper Phocas. The Excubitors deserted, the city opened, and Phocas was killed — by Heraclius’s own hand in some accounts, after the exchange “Is this how you have ruled?” / “And will you rule better?” On 5 October, in the chapel of St Stephen in the Great Palace, Patriarch Sergius crowned him, and he married Fabia, who took the name Eudocia. He inherited a wreck: Avars in the Balkans, Khosrow II already using Maurice’s murder as a pretext for war. Syria, Palestine and Egypt would fall; the True Cross would be carried off. Heraclius’s answer was personal command, a rebuilt army, and the campaign that ended at Nineveh in 627. The peace he won was brief. Within a decade the same provinces were lost again, this time to the Arabs.

816 — Louis the Pious crowned at Reims. Louis was already emperor. Charlemagne had crowned him co-emperor at Aachen on 11 September 813, and he had ruled alone since his father’s death in 814. Pope Stephen IV came north anyway. On Sunday 5 October, during Mass at Reims, Stephen anointed him and set on his head a crown said to have been Constantine’s. Ermengarde was crowned with him and hailed Augusta. Louis had prostrated himself before the pope. The act did not make him emperor; it reattached the imperial title to a papal coronation, which Charlemagne’s 813 ceremony had sidestepped. Reims became the place where French kings were crowned.

869 — the council that deposed Photius. The Fourth Council of Constantinople, counted in the West as the eighth ecumenical council, opened on 5 October 869 and sat until 28 February 870. Emperor Basil I and Pope Adrian II wanted Photius out. Photius, a lay scholar raised abruptly to the patriarchate in 858, had been deposed once, restored, and had anathematised Pope Nicholas I in 867. The council restored Ignatius, anathematised Photius, burned the acts of his 867 synod, and issued 27 canons. Attendance was thin — a dozen bishops at the start, never more than about a hundred. The East does not receive it. Photius was patriarch again from 877, and the council of 879–80, far better attended, rehabilitated him. This is one of the fractures that later hardened into the schism.

1143 — Portugal recognised at Zamora. On 5 October, at Zamora, with the papal legate Cardinal Guido de Vico present, Alfonso VII of León and Castile — who styled himself emperor of the Spains — acknowledged his cousin Afonso Henriques as king of Portugal. Afonso had already won the field against his mother at São Mamede in 1128 and had used the royal title after Ourique in 1139. The text of the treaty is lost. What survived is the political fact: the Leonese crown stopped contesting the title, and Afonso signed as rex Portugallensis. Full papal recognition waited until Alexander III’s bull Manifestis Probatum in 1179. Portugal still marks 5 October, though the modern national holiday is the republic of 1910, not Zamora.

1450 — Jews expelled from Lower Bavaria. Louis IX, Duke of Bavaria-Landshut, called Louis the Rich, ordered the Jews out of his part of Bavaria. This sits in the long fifteenth-century squeeze on German Jewish communities — debt cancellation dressed as piety, local expulsions before the larger ones of the 1490s. It was not the end of Jewish life in all Bavaria; Regensburg’s community lasted until 1519. It was a ducal clearance of Lower Bavaria.

1550 — Concepción founded. Pedro de Valdivia founded the city on 5 October 1550, at Penco on the Bay of Concepción, as a southern anchor of Spanish Chile against the Mapuche frontier. Earthquakes and Araucanian war forced later moves; the modern city stands inland of that first site. The date is the official foundation.

1582 — a day that did not happen. Pope Gregory XIII’s bull cut ten days from October so that the spring equinox, and therefore Easter, would fall where the Council of Nicaea had put it. In Italy, Spain, Portugal and the Polish–Lithuanian lands, 4 October was followed by 15 October. The 5th through the 14th do not exist in those countries for that year. France waited until December; Protestant states longer; Britain until 1752.

1607 — the knives and Paolo Sarpi. Sarpi, a Servite friar and Venice’s theological adviser in the Interdict fight with Paul V, was attacked on the night of 5 October as he came down the bridge by Santa Fosca toward his convent. Five men; fifteen thrusts by the count of holes in hat, hood and collar; three wounds that landed, one stiletto left in the cheekbone. He lived. Asked who had done it, he said Agnosco stylum Romanae Curiae — “I recognise the style of the Roman Curia,” with stilus also meaning dagger. The attackers fled toward the papal nuncio’s house and on to Rome. Venice gave him a safer lodging. He went back to his work on the history of the Council of Trent.

1665 — Kiel. Christian Albert, Duke of Holstein-Gottorp, founded the university on 5 October. It still bears his name: Christian-Albrechts-Universität.

1789 — the women march to Versailles. On the morning of 5 October, women from the Paris markets, after days of bread shortage and rumour, set off for Versailles. They wanted grain, and they wanted the king to sanction the August decrees and the Declaration of the Rights of Man. The National Guard followed under Lafayette, partly to lead the march and partly to keep it from becoming a sack. That night and the next morning the palace was invaded; two guards were killed. On the 6th Louis XVI agreed to move to Paris. The court came back to the Tuileries in the train of the crowd. The revolution ceased to be something that happened at a safe distance from the king.

1793 — the calendar, not a single act of abolition. Lists often say Christianity was disestablished in France on this day. What the Convention actually did on 5 October 1793 was accept Gilbert Romme’s scheme for a republican era beginning on 22 September 1792, the day the Republic had been proclaimed. The calendar itself was decreed on 24 October and backdated. Sunday disappeared; saints’ days were replaced by the names of plants, tools and weather; the aim was to take Christian time out of ordinary life. Dechristianisation was already a campaign — closed churches, the Cult of Reason, death for non-juring priests and those who hid them — not a statute passed on the 5th that ended the faith by decree. The Republican calendar lasted until 1806.

The day runs from a change of empire in Babylon to a change of calendar in Paris, with coronations, a council, a new kingdom and a failed killing in between.

Read full Article
post photo preview
The Great Game was not fought in Europe.
And yet Great Britain and Russia faced off.

The Great Game was not fought in Europe.

And yet Great Britain and Russia faced off.

The Crimean War was not a campaign of the Great Game. It was the one moment when the same rivalry was fought in Europe, with fleets and allies, instead of by envoys, subsidies and buffer states on the road to India.
The Game was the Anglo-Russian contest for the land between the two empires: Persia, Afghanistan, the khanates of Central Asia, and the passes that led down to the Indus. Britain’s fear, stated from the 1830s on, was simple. A Russia that kept marching south would one day stand on the Hindu Kush, or turn Persia into a dependency, and threaten India without ever fighting a European war. Russia’s interest was the reverse: warm water, a compliant neighbour on its southern frontier, and room to expand once the Ottomans and the steppe khanates weakened. The instruments were familiar long before 1853. The First Anglo-Afghan War of 1839–42 had already been fought to put a friendly ruler in Kabul. Herat, the western gate of Afghanistan, was watched every time Persia, with Russian encouragement, moved against it. Treaties with Tehran and St Petersburg drew lines that neither side trusted.
What happened on 4 October 1853 sat on the other end of the same map. Nicholas I was not marching on the Khyber. He had occupied the Danubian Principalities and was demanding a protectorate over the sultan’s Orthodox subjects, with Constantinople and the Straits as the prize if the empire broke. For Britain that was the western door of the same problem. A Russian fleet in the Black Sea, and a Russian say over the passage into the Mediterranean, threatened the sea route toward India as surely as Cossacks on the Oxus threatened the land route. Palmerston and the men around him did not treat the two theatres as separate quarrels. The “sick man” and the buffer states were one strategic question: where Russia would be stopped.
That is why Britain entered a war whose battlefield was the Crimea and whose formal cause was a dispute over churches in Palestine. France had its own reasons, Napoleon III among them. Austria feared Russian possession of the lower Danube. The Ottomans were fighting for the principalities and for the claim that the sultan, not the tsar, protected the Christians of the empire. Britain was fighting to keep Russia out of Constantinople and the Straits, and to show that the check could be made to hold. The Treaty of Paris in March 1856 did that for a generation. Russia lost southern Bessarabia, accepted the neutralisation of the Black Sea, and saw the Ottoman Empire placed under a European guarantee.
The Game did not end with that treaty. It sharpened, because the Black Sea door had been shut. Unable to push through the Straits, Russia turned east. Tashkent fell in 1865, Samarkand in 1868, Khiva in 1873, Kokand in 1876, Merv in 1884. Each advance shortened the distance to Herat and to India, and each produced a British answer: a forward policy on the north-west frontier, the Second Anglo-Afghan War of 1878–80, the Penjdeh crisis of 1885, when Russian and Afghan troops clashed and Britain and Russia came close to war again. The men who had beaten Russia at Sevastopol spent the next thirty years arguing over how far the Indian garrison should go to meet the next Russian column.
So the October declaration belongs at the hinge, not inside the Game itself. It was the Eastern Question fought to a decision, by coalition, in sight of the European capitals. The Great Game was what remained when that decision closed the sea and left the land. The rivalry that produced Sinope and the Alma is the same rivalry that produced the Afghan wars and the race for Merv. Only the ground changed.
=
On 4 October 1853 the Sublime Porte declared war on Russia. The manifesto was read in the mosques of Constantinople that day, the first of the Ottoman year, and published in the official paper Takvim-i Vekayi. Notes went to the British, French, Austrian and Prussian embassies. The text was deliberately calm. It said Russia had occupied Ottoman territory and had refused to leave, so the sultan was forced to fight. It also gave the Russian commander on the Danube fifteen days to evacuate. Hostilities did not legally begin until that grace expired and the answer came back no.
The quarrel had been building for a year, and the holy places were only the match. In Palestine, French-backed Latins and Russian-backed Orthodox monks had disputed keys, a silver star, and precedence at the Church of the Nativity and the Holy Sepulchre. Napoleon III wanted a Catholic victory he could show at home. Tsar Nicholas I treated the Orthodox claim as a right of protection over some twelve million Ottoman Christians. In the spring of 1853 Prince Menshikov arrived in Constantinople demanding a formal protectorate. Sultan Abdülmecid, stiffened by the British ambassador Stratford Canning, refused. Nicholas had already called the empire “the sick man of Europe” and sounded Vienna and London on a partition. Neither would bite. In July his troops crossed the Prut and occupied the Danubian Principalities, Moldavia and Wallachia, still under Ottoman suzerainty. Britain ordered its fleet toward Constantinople on 23 September. With French and British promises in hand, the Porte chose war rather than accept the occupation as a fact.
Ömer Pasha, the Austrian-born convert who commanded the army of Rumelia, sent the ultimatum to Prince Mikhail Gorchakov on 8 October. Gorchakov answered on the 10th that his master was not at war with Turkey, but that he had orders not to leave until the emperor received “moral satisfaction,” and that if attacked he would stand on the defensive. From that refusal the war was open. Turkish troops crossed the Danube later in the month. They fought a holding campaign and checked the Russian advance at Silistra. On 30 November a Russian squadron under Nakhimov destroyed an Ottoman fleet at anchor in Sinope. That shock, more than the October manifesto, pulled Britain and France across the line. Their fleets entered the Black Sea on 3 January 1854. They declared war on 28 March.
What followed is remembered as the Crimean War, though the fighting ran from the Danube to the Caucasus to the Baltic. Britain, France and, from January 1855, Piedmont-Sardinia joined the Ottomans. The allies landed in Crimea in September 1854, won the Alma, endured the siege of Sevastopol through a winter that killed more men by disease than by shot, and took the city in September 1855. Nicholas died in March 1855. His son Alexander II accepted preliminary terms in February 1856. The Treaty of Paris, 30 March 1856, restored the principalities, stripped Russia of southern Bessarabia and the right to keep a fleet on the Black Sea, and put the integrity of the Ottoman Empire under a European guarantee.
The October declaration did not save the empire. It postponed a partition and bought a generation under that guarantee. The same war broke the Concert of Europe that had held since 1815, made Florence Nightingale and the telegraph part of how battles were seen at home, and left Russia determined to undo the Black Sea clauses, which it did in 1871. The quarrel over a star in Bethlehem had become a war about who would inherit the Ottoman south and the Black Sea shore.
=
October 4 is a day of fallen capitals, broken calendars, and men who seized a city or a fleet and found the throne still one fight away. The entries you listed sit mostly on that date. Two of them spill onto the 5th: Heraclius was crowned the morning after he landed, and Napoleon’s grapeshot fell on 13 Vendémiaire, which is 5 October 1795, after the sections had already declared themselves in revolt on the 4th.
Chang’an, AD 23. Wang Mang had taken the Han throne in AD 9 and called his dynasty the Xin, the New. Famine, debased coin, and land edicts that never quite worked fed two peasant armies, the Lulin in the south and the Red Eyebrows on the plain. In spring 23 the Lulin put a Han prince, Liu Xuan, on a throne of their own. By early October their columns and a rising inside the walls had Chang’an. On 4 October rebels broke an eastern gate. Wang Mang, in purple, still holding the imperial seals, tried ritual defence rather than flight. At dawn on 6 October his last attendants made a stand on the Terrace Bathed by Water. A merchant, Du Wu, killed him. His head was cut off and shown. The Xin died with him. The Han restoration that followed was not the one the Lulin had planned: within two years Liu Xiu, the future Guangwu, had outlasted both them and the Red Eyebrows.
Constantinople, 610. Phocas had murdered Maurice in 602 and spent eight years losing the east to the Persians. Heraclius, son of the exarch of Africa, sailed from Carthage, entered the Golden Horn, and was received as the alternative the city had already half-chosen. He reached Constantinople on 3–4 October. On 5 October Patriarch Sergius crowned him in the chapel of St Stephen inside the Great Palace. Phocas was dragged out and killed. The reign that began that week would last until 641, lose Syria and Egypt to the Arabs, and still be remembered for the counter-stroke that broke Khosrow II.
Marrakesh, 1227. Abdallah al-Adil was an Almohad prince who had already had his predecessor strangled in 1224. The coup split the dynasty. Andalusian rivals and Castile picked at the edges. On 4 October 1227 he was drowned in a palace bath in Marrakesh, and his nephew Yahya al-Mutasim was put up in his place. The murder settled nothing. Within a generation the Almohad caliphate was gone from Spain and failing in the Maghreb.
Venice and the lake, 1302 and 1363. On 4 October 1302 Byzantium and Venice closed the war that had run since 1296. Andronikos II bought peace: Venetian prisoners released, trading rights restored, a war indemnity. It was a truce in a rivalry that would outlast both signatories. Sixty-one years later, on the same date, the Battle of Lake Poyang ended. From late August, Zhu Yuanzhang’s smaller, faster craft had harried Chen Youliang’s tower-ships on the great lake in Jiangxi. On 4 October an arrow killed Chen. His Han state collapsed with him. Zhu, once a novice monk, was five years from founding the Ming.
Rome, London, and the Georgia coast. On 4 October 1511 Ferdinand of Aragon, Pope Julius II, and Venice formed the Holy League against Louis XII’s France. England and the Swiss joined later. Julius’s slogan was “out with the barbarians.” The league drove the French from Milan in 1512 and then fell apart, Venice changing sides again in 1513. On 4 October 1535 the first complete printed English Bible, Miles Coverdale’s, came off the press in Antwerp or Cologne, depending on the imprint one trusts. Coverdale worked from Latin and German where he lacked Hebrew and Greek, and folded in William Tyndale’s banned New Testament and Pentateuch. Henry VIII’s England was not yet ready to own it; the book still fixed the shape of what English readers would call Scripture. On 4 October 1582 Pope Gregory XIII’s reform took effect in Italy, Spain, Portugal, and Poland. Thursday the 4th was followed by Friday the 15th. Ten dates, including a 5 October, never happened there. The Julian calendar had drifted about ten days from the sun. Britain waited until 1752. On 4 October 1597 the Guale of the Georgia coast rose against the Spanish Franciscan missions. The spark was a quarrel over chiefly succession and mission interference at Tolomato; friars were killed, Santa Catalina and other stations abandoned. Spain reimposed the missions within a year. The rising is read now as a faction fight among Guale elites as much as a simple rejection of the cross.
Wittstock and Marsaglia. On 4 October 1636 Johan Banér’s Swedes, outnumbered, beat a Saxon–Imperial army at Wittstock in Brandenburg. Banér refused the frontal slope, hooked the allied right through woods, and turned a defensive position into a rout. It kept Sweden in the German war after the disaster at Nördlingen. On 4 October 1693 Marshal Catinat beat Victor Amadeus II of Savoy on the plain near Orbassano, the fight named Marsaglia after the farm where Catinat wrote his report. French line infantry went in with bayonets; Irish Brigade regiments fought in the French ranks. Allied losses ran near 10,000 and the guns. Piedmont stayed in the war, but the siege of Pinerolo was broken.
Philadelphia twice, and Paris. On 4 October 1777 Washington attacked Howe’s camp at Germantown in fog. The plan was a convergent strike by four columns. It broke down in the mist, at the stone Chew House, and in friendly fire. The British held. The attack still showed Congress and France that the Continental Army could strike a field army in the open. On 4 October 1779 militia in Philadelphia, angry at price controls lifted and at lawyers who had defended accused Loyalists, marched on the house of James Wilson, signer of the Declaration. Wilson and friends barricaded “Fort Wilson” and fired. Captain Campbell was killed inside; several militia died in the street. Joseph Reed’s cavalry broke it up. Radical militia and conservative merchants had been allies in 1776. Fort Wilson showed they no longer were. On 4 October 1795 Paris sections were already repudiating the National Convention; the next morning, 5 October, about 25,000 royalists moved on the Tuileries. Paul Barras had the defence. He handed the guns to Napoleon Bonaparte, who had spent the previous evening at the theatre. Grapeshot in the rue Saint-Honoré, in front of Saint-Roch, ended the rising in an afternoon. Bonaparte’s reward was command of the Army of Italy.
The day keeps returning to the same bargain: a capital taken, a fleet sunk, a treaty signed, a bible printed, ten days deleted from the year. None of those acts finished the argument. Wang Mang’s head did not restore the Han he had displaced. Heraclius inherited a war he would spend thirty years fighting. Zhu’s arrow on the lake opened the Ming and did not close China’s civil wars. Coverdale’s book and Gregory’s missing fortnight both tried to fix what people believed and when they believed the sun stood, and both took centuries to settle.
Read full Article
See More
Available on mobile and TV devices
google store google store app store app store
google store google store app tv store app tv store amazon store amazon store roku store roku store
Powered by Locals